REPUBLIC, Mo. — Nolan Lashley made the two most important plays of the third overtime, scoring the go-ahead touchdown and then pressuring Carthage quarterback Slade Stiffler on the conversion attempt that sealed Republic’s 32–30 victory Friday, November 6. The Class 5 District 6 semifinal was tied after regulation and after each of the first two overtime periods before the Tigers finally prevailed.
Carthage struck first when Stiffler broke away for a 46-yard touchdown run. Republic responded with two sustained drives. On fourth-and-four during the first, Cooper Cornelsen found Baelor Cutbirth for 34 yards, and Cornelsen scored on an eight-yard run to tie the game. The Tigers then traveled 71 yards on 13 plays, converting two fourth-and-one situations before Lashley ran one yard for a 14–7 advantage. The lead held through halftime after Carthage’s final drive stalled on fourth down near the Republic goal line.
The second half belonged to the defenses for long stretches. Carthage recovered an onside kick to begin the third quarter, but Republic stopped that possession on fourth down. Stiffler later finished another drive with a 10-yard touchdown run, tying the game 14–14. Neither team scored again in regulation, setting up the extended finish.
Cutbirth scored on a 25-yard run on Republic’s first overtime snap, and Karter Manzer answered from three yards out for Carthage. In the second overtime, Malachi Dougless kicked a 30-yard field goal to give Carthage a 24–21 lead. Ethan Blades replied with a 21-yard field goal after Republic’s possession stalled, leaving the teams tied at 24.
Lashley then took the opening snap of the third overtime 25 yards for a touchdown and added the two-point conversion. Manzer’s six-yard touchdown on fourth-and-one brought Carthage within 32–30. On the tying attempt, Lashley, who had not played defense during the season, lined up on that side of the ball and chased Stiffler from behind. The quarterback’s hurried pass fell incomplete, preserving Republic’s lead.
Republic rushed for 315 yards on 58 attempts and finished with 357 yards of offense. Cutbirth led the Tigers with 122 rushing yards on 17 carries, Lashley added 120 yards on 28 attempts and Cornelsen ran for 66 yards. Stiffler rushed for 119 yards and two touchdowns for Carthage while completing 10 of 13 passes for 61 yards. The Republic defense held Carthage to 229 total yards despite the three overtime periods.
The win improved Republic to 9–1, eliminated a 7–4 Carthage team and sent the Tigers into the district championship game against Neosho. It was Republic’s second victory over Carthage in three weeks after years of difficulty against its rival, and it came down to one defender finishing the final play.

